Thursday, April 03, 2008

Improved health care under the PPP/C government

At the Georgetown Public Hospital Corporation (GPHC), it is alleged that a doctor mis-treated and assaulted a patient while using racial slurs. Such conduct cannot be condoned in Guyana at any time, but it is even more dangerous during the fragile crime, security situation and fraying race relations.
Ms. Charmian De Mendonca has said in a statement that she was treated with great insensitivity by one Dr. Kishore Persaud when she was admitted to the Georgetown Hospital on Wednesday, March 26, 2008. Ms. Mendonca has stated that while coming out of unconsciousness after an accident at the corners of Cummings and Charlotte Streets, she felt someone pulling at her right ears and recognised the person to be Dr. Kishore Persaud. She protested and asked him to stop as this was causing her pain. Dr. Persaud then started to hit Ms. Mendonca in her chest causing further pain and when she insisted that he must desist from such action, he became angry and said “well if you feeling pain get up and go outside, yall black people like to come here and waste people time.”
According to Ms. Mendonca, Dr. Persaud after returning from his desk took off her oxygen mask in a manner which caused the elastic strap to sting her in her face several times. He continued the abuse of the patient despite the physical and emotional pain she was in and continued the racial abuse by saying “you want mek yo self a black fool and got me hey all night, I have to go home.” Dr. Persaud then scraped between Ms. Mendonca second and third toes on her right foot, until it bled and further order that she be taken off the spinal board.
The PNCR, which is the weakest main opposition party in Latin American and the Caribbean, said it considers this an outrage and demands that an urgent investigation into this matter be conducted. If such an investigation finds that Dr. Kishore Persaud is guilty of mis-conduct he must be appropriately sanctioned and adequate compensation paid to Ms. Mendonca.

As promised, transcript of Hinckson interview

This interview was conducted by Mark Benschop the day after the press conference where Mr. Hinckson allegedly uttered the seditious statements that he is now charged for.Mr. Hinckson, as an ex-officer in the Guyana Defence Force and someone who has been standing up for all Guyanese in the past and even today –


Mark Benschop:


You have been commissioned by the Queen of England – obviously you are in a position to analyze what is happening in Guyana today.


Oliver Hinckson:


We have had reports of the joint services smashing down doors and breaking up people’s television sets and other personal property. We have seen, from a military perspective, that this is not the way to go. In any aspect of warfare, the emphasis must be on winning the hearts and minds of the civilian population. And if our army, our joint service should go in this direction, clearly there will be no cooperation from the civilian population. We have witnessed a ninety-three year old woman trembling in her boots, about to keel over in front of soldiers. This is not nice. It doesn’t speak well for the GDF and it drives fear into the populace.


Mark Benschop:


With regards to what you have just said about civilians not cooperating with the joint services – where is our country heading if the people do not have confidence in the joint services?


Oliver Hinckson:


That would be extended to the government itself, which is more a regime than a government of all the people. If they don’t have confidence in the people who are supposed to safeguard their security and safety, their very lives as well, by extension they will say that the government is responsible for this and they are clearly heading down the wrong road.


Mark Benschop:


Having said that, do you feel that the GDF has been infiltrated by notorious drug criminals?


Oliver Hinckson:


Evidence in the past showed that at least two army officers had been interdicted from duty for trying to make contact with drug lords. But I would not be so presumptuous to say that that esteemed institution has been infiltrated by drug lords.


Mark Benschop:


Would you say that the government has hijacked the army?


Oliver Hinckson:


Clearly the office of the upper echelon of the army has become virtually innocuous. We have seen the establishment of the MCID and, I think there is something else called the PID and another branch. These are, as I mentioned, Gestapo-like, KGB elements. We know that the government originally was communist. They are still dyed-in-the-wool socialists, and these are old techniques that have been used for infiltrating the bureaucracy. But what was pointed out recently but someone in the press is that it appears that this very bureaucracy, the military and the police are not solidly behind the president.


Mark Benschop:


And would you consider this to be a very dangerous situation?


Oliver Hinckson:


Well we can all wait and see if we are not all dead by then at the hands of these jack booted, Gestapo type elements within the army.


Mark Benschop:


We have witnessed, for the first time in our country’s history, a head of the army pledging allegiance to the government of the day – I’m speaking about Commodore Gary Best who, during his inauguration, said that he is pledging his full support or allegiance to the government. How do you interpret Commodore Best’s statement as an ex army officer?


Oliver Hinckson:


On the face of it, it would appear as though the Chief of Staff was speaking for the entire army. But you know the sentiments of the individual soldier would lie within his breast, and perhaps, by mistake, he was trying to say that the army, as in the old British times, should be supportive of the government of the day and not too intimately and intricately involved in the politics of the government. He should have come back subsequently and clarified that statement because a lot of people took offence at it. But one wonders when you notice the venom and the eagerness with which senior officers of the military seem to want to carry out the requests, orders and instructions of venal and corrupt politicians, it leaves you to wonder whether we are heading down a dangerous path.


Mark Benschop:


Let’s take what Commodore Best has said about his allegiance to the government of the day and compare it with Mr Jagdeo saying that he doesn’t wish for anyone to pledge allegiance to him. What do you think?


Oliver Hinckson:


I did not hear or cannot recall that but if that was said, clearly it seems to be the president’s way of handling things. There seems to be no proper order and very many people seem to be putting their foot in their mouth.


Mark Benschop:


Let’s talk about the killings now. In this country we talk about seeing children gunned down. We are talking about several villages. There was a young boy who was gunned down in Buxton among other instances. What do you think of the wanton killing of children in these times?


Oliver Hinckson:


It is a horrific incident at all times and it must impact upon the senses of humanity. We have seen this government pass legislation in regards to the abortion act. And that, to my mind, is, in itself, murder of an unborn child. We have seen the Minister of Health publicly declaring that the Public Hospital of Georgetown is the ideal and perfect place to go and have an abortion. When this act was passed, there was a great hue and cry and public demonstrations clearly showing that not very many people were in agreement with such a move. But at the basis of it is the fact that the government has condoned murder. We have seen Minister Gail Texieira at the time when there was the Rosehall bank robbery publicly declaring that those robbers must be killed. Must be killed! Since when is the penalty for bank robbery death? A man is entitled to be tried before a panel of jurors of his peers, and if found guilty, there are stipulated penalties for such crimes. But the penalty for bank robbery, I assure you, is not death. But we have descended into that. We have seen ‘Gangster’ line up six men, six young boys, and execute them and is now walking the road without a charge under this regime. We have seen a little boy executed in Agricola, another one at Bagotstown and even the children at Lusignan, but this a tragic past. The society we live in must look at itself in the mirror and ask itself questions; how am I to blame? Did I contribute in anyway to this? Did I allow a government and a president who are careening down the road like a runaway bus taking us all down a destructive path? Did I allow this without lifting a finger to stop this from happening?


Mark Benschop:


So what you are saying is that the genesis of the killing, especially of little children under the PPP regime (and I am quite sure that people like Dr. Leslie Ramsammy and Gail Texieira would wish to rebut) started with the Abortion Act. What we see in our country today is pretty obvious to everyone and that is, the regime seems to be condoning murders committed by one group of known criminals, the Phantom against young black men. How could we possibly tolerate a government of that nature?


Oliver Hinckson:


Well, those actions do not surprise me. We are dealing with an unconscionable set of people. We have the Minister of Health, who has removed the dialysis machine from the public hospital and put them somewhere else where nobody knows and at the present moment there are no dialysis machines at the Public Hospital after the Muslim community had donated two. Now I spoke to a matron at the hospital and she said that once you go there with a kidney problem you are condemned to die because the minister has removed the machines. Where are they? Are they at another hospital? Are they being used in a mercenary fashion? Are they being used in a way where there is a kickback? These are questions that the minister must answer. I can recall reading in the newspapers that these two machines were found in the minister’s office instead of the clinic where they could have been used for the general good. We are dealing with people who consider human life inconsequential.


Mark Benschop:


Would you say that we are dealing with a regime that considers a black person’s life as being inconsequential?


Oliver Hinckson:


From all appearances this is very self evident. We have seen a great brouhaha whenever there is a murder in an Indian village but when there is a murder in black villages such as Agricola or Bagotstown no government ministers go there. No Indian government minister goes there. This is not to say that Indian people are not good. Some of my very best friends are Indian and I believe that this country belongs to all of us regardless of his ethnicity but there is a fascist clique within the government that has adopted very supercilious attitude and it looks down in arrogance, especially at the lives of the black man. Cheddi Jagan himself said that the blacks are at the bottom rung of the social ladder. Maybe he knows what he is talking about. Maybe he did an empirical study of this. But if you and I were to do an empirical study of the loss of lives of Indians and compare it to blacks in Guyana you would see that too many blacks have been killed. Out of the 434 youths who were killed from 2002, the vast majority were blacks, and they were killed in an extra-judicial manner. This is not nice. It is unacceptable. If you president of a nation, then you must show compassion for all the people, and this is clearly not the case.


Mark Benschop:


Corporal Ivor Williams, who was laid to rest a few days back, was buried without any member of government in attendance at his funeral to pay their respects. How do you think the twenty thousand odd ex-soldiers along with the young ones currently serving would view this?


Oliver Hinckson:

You can take a look at Corporal Ivor Williams and see that he was a fine young man and it bleeds the heart of every soldier to know that one of their comrades in arms was killed in the line of duty, and who is to say that it is the bandits that shot at that patrol, knowing the politicians and knowing the communists. They would try any act, any nefarious act. I have my suspicions about the death of Corporal Williams. I will go as far as laying blame equally at the feet of the politicians as well as the bandits. As a soldier, the treatment of Ivor Williams smacks of disrespect on all soldiers and lack of consideration for the life of a young man and all the young men who would put their lives on the line for this country. Who have put their lives in the past Ancoco, Lethem, New River and Buxton and who are willing to put their lives on the line in the future. The shabby treatment of Corporal Williams, which we saw vividly the impact it had on his relatives, the packing of his coffin with newspapers. That is just bad form. It is bad form and there is no way that whoever was responsible for this will go back and apologise to this family. The damage has already been done. The military must now step up their act and stop acting like house slaves and lackeys. Stop it. In third world countries the military has a very important and consequential say in matters, whether political or otherwise. Because how they respond as the ultimate coercive force will ultimately have an impact on the lives of all the people, and therefore they must put their foot down on a very arrogant, corrupt and abrasive government. I am categorically stating that nobody is saying you must rise in mutiny. Nobody is saying that. We are saying this categorically – nobody is saying we must rise up in mutiny But at the same time the leaders must say, “You are going too far. It cannot work and we advise you not to go in this direction.” Merely speaking as the military can have a great influence on outcomes and outputs in this society.


Mark Benschop:


The operations that have been going on in Buxton where they are kicking down doors, harassing woman and brutalising children - would you say that this is the legitimate role of the army where there is the absence of a state of emergency?


Oliver Hinckson:


The military may be used when crime transcends itself from crime into acts of terrorism. There is a thin red line between the two. If a man goes out and snatches a purse and stabs the victim with a knife, that is basic crime. If the crime is narco-trafficking, and we have seen Guyana in the forefront of that, even reaching as far as Italy now, we have seen big drug dealers arrested and incarcerated in the United States. If narco-trafficking moves itself from just basic selling of drugs and the proceeds are used for terrorism, then we can see the military coming in here and putting a stop to that aspect of crime, that type of crime.


Mark Benschop:


When you say ‘putting a stop’ precisely what do you mean? Because we have experienced that with the hunting down of the US fugitive Roger Khan who is now facing a drug charge in the US. Are you saying that the army should have taken full control of the situation?


Oliver Hinckson:


The army was part of the situation. They were quite integral and mainly part of the joint service operations that flushed him out because he had gone into hiding with the disappearance of the weapons. And the pressure was so much, he fled across the border to Suriname, and was apprehended there. Had it not been for the military then, he would not have been flushed out. Because the US has said that the government of Guyana, this present government has not been cooperative and collaborative with the efforts to apprehend and extradite drug dealers. But the military must know where the cut off point is. I am saying in basic day to day crime fighting operations, the police have the capacity to handle that.


Mark Benschop:


Where do we go from here as a nation with regards to our citizens who are dissatisfied? I am talking about all our citizens because we have witnessed what happened in Lusignan and the immediate protest thereafter where the people laid the blame squarely at the feet of the government quite vociferously.


Oliver Hinckson:


Well we know for sure where we are heading. We are heading down a slippery slope towards our doom and we must all, as a nation, stand up and say enough is enough. We have lived wonderfully with each other for the longest while, since 1964 to now without incidents like this. The people themselves have gotten fed up of being used especially by the clique within the PPP. And I made a suggestion that we must all sit at the table, all those who have the goodwill and the interest of the people at heart, must sit at the table. The pie must be divided in a proportionate way and everybody must be able to feel satisfied. Freddie Kisson wrote a beautiful article outlining the lifespan of all autocratic regimes, and clearly the Jagdeo regime is in full decline. There will be no coming back because his own people have turned against him. He cannot lie to them anymore. He cannot con them anymore. For one silly moment he thought that the people loved him more than they loved the PPP. They loved Cheddie and they love the PPP and if he were to leave the PPP to form his own party, he would get a rude awakening. The way forward for Guyana is togetherness, sharing the pie, some people call it shared governance, and I feel more authority, more responsibility must be placed in the hands of the local organisations.


Mark Benschop:


You have recently said that you want to see the healing of this nation but your remarks incurred the wrath of the government when you said that you are willing work towards bringing all parties together to reach some sort of understanding. Further controversy was invoked by your taking umbrage at the fact that they are referring to these gunmen as bandits, preferring instead the term insurgents. How do you propose to bring these parties together?


Oliver Hinckson:


Individuals who have a stake in this whole problem, not only government officials, but people like the village chairman, because Buxton has been highly offended. It has been demonised like so many black leaders and black villages. The chairman of Buxton, someone who has a connect with the insurgents, who can speak to them. He may not be able to go wherever they are geographically, but he would have known by now the mindset of these men, and what is it that is their grievance, what is their beef and what are their hopes and aspirations, not only for themselves, but for the nation. Then there are other people; political parties, civil society. Every time there is a problem, some confrontation between the insurgents and the military, the streets are bare and businesses are affected. So there are very many people who have an interest in this. There can be preliminary talks because I know that an insurgent is not going to put down his gun and come to any table himself. He is going to send his emissary and that emissary must be safeguarded of course. But, as I said, I and some of my people who are ex-military are willing to go into Buxton and speak to the chairman, speak to the emissary, speak to whoever it is and act as a go between. If you go into Buxton representing evil, chances are you will be shot at by the insurgents. I think I have the credibility with the young people, whether they are military, ex-military, insurgents, emissaries, I believe that I have the capacity to talk to these people and act as a go between. It is being done in the field of diplomacy and I am willing to put my life at risk. I know that the PPP is riddled with cowards, I am prepared to put my life on the line, if there is any risk at all, and venture to wherever the emissary may be, and bring this thing to a peaceful resolution.

Toys arrive

When the Government said they were purchasing helicopters for the army, we had no idea they had gone to China to buy toys. Is this the "Best" the Chief of Staff and Government can come up with to fight criminals with heavy firepower? Waste of money and the next thing Rohee will tell the Parliament, is the Government delivered on its promise. We should put the President and the Chief of staff in one of these lead-tainted copters and fly them over the back lands.

Developing story...

Guyana alone not "Chasing" thiefing reporters

IN CAYMAN ISLANDS

A former Caymanian politician and journalist was charged Wednesday with burglary, making false accusations, making a false report to police and intending to pervert the administration of public justice.

The burglary charge against Lyndon Martin relates to a break–in which police said occurred in the personal office of Cayman Net News publisher Desmond Seales. Investigators said Mr. Martin intended to steal documentation from the office during the alleged burglary.

Mr. Martin had worked at the Net News until his arrest on Thursday, according to Mr. Seales.

The other charges are related to false accusations police said Mr. Martin made against Mr. Seales. Police said the newspaper publisher and a deputy police commissioner, Anthony Ennis, were alleged to have shared confidential information and that the two were allegedly involved in a “corrupt relationship.”

Senior Investigating Officer Martin Bridger said Mr. Martin’s allegations were simply not true.

Mr. Martin faces five counts each of falsely accusing another of a crime, and of making a false report of the commission of an offence.

Neither he nor his attorney was reachable by press time.

“Making a false report to police is a serious offence,” read a statement issued by Mr. Bridger Wednesday morning. “It has the potential to cause serious personal and professional damage for those being falsely accused and it diverts police resources from other matters.”

In a court appearance Wednesday, Mr. Martin was refused bail on the charges and remanded to Northward Prison.


IN GUYANA


A former court reporter accused of stealing a camera from a woman was remanded to prison when he appeared at the Leonora Magistrate’s Court on Tuesday.
Travis Chase, 21, of 80 Prince William Street, Plaisance pleaded not guilty to a charge of larceny from the dwelling house and was remanded to prison by Magistrate Fazil Azeez.
It is alleged that on March 22 at Meten-Meer-Zorg, West Coast Demerara, Chase stole from the dwelling of Anjanie Singh a digital camera valued at $120,000.

Reports are that Chase had been invited to partake in Phagwah celebrations by the virtual complainant at her home on that date but when he left it was noticed that the camera was missing. Subsequent investigations reportedly revealed that the accused had the item in his possession. The matter was reported and he was arrested and charged.

Attorney-at-law Lawrence Harris while not representing Chase told the court that he knew the defendant and Chase had worked as a court reporter for MTV Channel 65 News Update.

He said that he knew him to be of good behaviour and asked that he be admitted to bail.
Bail was refused and Chase was remanded to prison. He will return to court on April 24 at the Leonora Magistrate’s Court.

Wednesday, April 02, 2008

Breaking news...."Kidnapping" in Georgetown

Unofficial sources told us a few hours ago that the owner/manager of Jiffy Lube, Farouk Kalamadeen has been reported missing in what appears to be an early morning kidnapping.

His family reported to police that the businessman left home for a walk. reports are sketchy and fishy. More to come.

Update: It is now 5 pm and there has been no sighting of the businessman. Further, relatives tell Guyana360 that no one has contacted them about his whereabouts.


Media critic asleep.

"HAITI, the most recent member of CARICOM, plans to make a first time appearance in the Caribbean Festival of Arts (Carifesta) X by showcasing its most unique and astonishing culture." Today's Guyana Chronicle.

Guyana360: Technically, Haiti joined CARICOM in July 2002, but CARICOM severed ties with the island following the ouster of Jean Bertrand Aristide by the US Government.

However, CARICOM resumed full relations with Haiti after the return of democracy following elections. So you folks at Guyana Chronicle, Haiti was the last to join CARICOM, but can 2002 be considered in the context of "most recent". It is not 2007 or 2006, it's 2002. We believe that your reporter is confusing the region's re-engagement with Haiti as against the island's entry into CARICOM.

The folks over at Livinguyana have been consumed by the nonsense that passes as journalism in Guyana. They now post one a day. A post a day will not keep the media honest.

Fire confirmation

Photo of fire plucked from today's Kaieteur News confirms our post yesterday. It also confirms that our sources are good and true, although we thought it was an April fool's joke. Thanks guys. We were also bale to confirm that Freddy Kissoon is safe and sound and this brings good/bad news for so many.


Bad excuse Chetty


GEORGETOWN, Guyana, CMC – Guyana Cricket Board (GCB) president, Chetram Singh said yesterday batsman Shivnarine Chanderpaul had sought permission to attend the West Indies Players Association (WIPA) awards ceremony, and had not abandoned the Guyana team during their final round Carib Beer Series match.


Singh, also a West Indies Cricket Board director, said the Test batsman had been granted permission by the GCB to attend the WIPA function on Sunday when he collected the three major awards.

Chanderpaul, who made an unbeaten 78 on the opening day on Saturday against the Windward Islands, was absent on the second day of the match on Sunday but match officials were given no explanation as to his whereabouts.

“Shiv asked to go before the match began and permission was granted. He agreed to play for his country which was good for the game, especially since (Ramnaresh) Sarwan was asked to rest from this game,” Singh explained.

“The idea was for him to leave after the day’s play and return the next day but no flight was available out of Guyana to Trinidad after 10:30 pm even though you could have travelled to Barbados in the evening.

“Shiv was forced to cut short his innings to catch that flight and as agreed he returned the next day even though the second Test was being played in Trinidad.”

Confusion mounted on the second day when Gajanand Singh came out to partner skipper Travis Dowlin instead of Chanderpaul at the start of the day on Sunday.

Match referee Omar Bacchus and the two umpires confirmed they were never officially informed about Chanderpaul’s absence by the Guyana camp and had no other choice than to rule him retired out.

Guyana manager Carl Moore also could not provide any explanation to the Windward Islands team concerning Chanderpaul’s absence and this upset the Windward Islands manager Lochart Sebastien, who later refused to allow Guyana a substitute fielder when his side batted.

When contacted for an explanation, Moore refused to comment on the matter while Guyana coach Albert Smith said he was not aware that Chanderpaul had been scheduled to leave on Sunday morning.

Moore’s failure to inform the match officials of Chanderpaul’s absence is expected to be documented in the match referee’s report on the game. Singh argued it had been Moore’s responsibility to ensure match officials were informed.

“The responsibility of the manager is to inform all the relevant parties that Shiv was not going to continue his innings and I would say that poor management caused all this confusion,” Singh said.

“I have been getting calls from foreign radio stations today (Tuesday) and this could have all been avoided if the manager had explained the situation at the start of the second day’s play.

“Chanderpaul has served Guyana and West Indies cricket well and I feel he deserved to have been allowed to personally collect his awards.

“He could have also requested some rest and missed the last round game, but in the absence of Sarwan he felt he needed to play. It was unfortunate that the unavailability of an afternoon flight resulted in him having to cut short his innings.

“The manager was informed that Shiv was leaving and I am at a loss as to way he felt it was not necessary to inform the relevant authorities.”

An upset Chanderpaul said he was disappointed that the lack of a proper explanation gave the impression that he just took off without anyone being informed.

Mc Coy , the Messenger

Stabroek News is aligned with the political opposition

April 2, 2008

Dear Editor,

Stabroek News’ Editor’s note to my letter captioned “Your report on the resurrection of a phantom squad shows bias” (08.03.30) cleverly evaded the real argument and resorted to semantics.

Throughout my letter, without any haziness my argument dwelled on Stabroek News sharing the agenda of the political opposition in Guyana.

The use of the March 25, Page 1 article, headlined: Has the phantom gang come out of retirement?’’ was merely an example in support of my argument. Instead the Editor chose to dive into semantics by blaming carelessness on my part for using ‘’resurrection’’ of the phantom gang in place of its original headline. The headline itself implies a resurrection of the gang though there is no evidence to support it even existed in the first place. However, for any group to come out of retirement means there was a resurrection of its previous interests, relevance and or activity. We basically agreed, let’s not quibble over semantics.

But why this attempt to cloud the real issue which surrounds Stabroek News’ strong partnership with the political opposition, using the free press to generate and promote hostility against the PPP/C Administration and propagating particular lines of the political opposition? Stabroek News plays a lead role in either advancing or repeating these particular lines.

It is an opportune moment, for the sake of clarity, to note that the PPP/C Administration has replaced an era of a suppressed and docile media with a predominantly critical free press.

During the PNC era Guyanese were accused of criticizing the Government even in the confines of their living room and faced serious consequences. Today, all over Guyana there is freedom of speech and freedom of the press. The media in Guyana criticize the Government, write about anything, and put forward all sorts of unfounded allegations.
I thought this would be necessary to mention so as to remove lingering doubts about the Government’s tenacity to criticisms. The fact that media practitioners and media houses ply their trade unhindered, demonstrates the PPP/C commitment to the principles of democracy.

In Stabroek News’ case my argument is specifically about its biases, and calculated propagation of the views and opinions of the political opposition. Even that is okay too but Stabroek News must first categorically admit for the ‘public good’ that it prefers a particular course. This follows that there are ethical and moral standards and values that must be upheld by a free and responsible press.

Yours faithfully,
Kwame Mc Coy

Editor’s note
From time immemorial governments have accused independent newspapers of supporting the opposition. Structurally this is because, as the main actor in the affairs of the state, governments inevitably attract the focus of editorial comment.
When this newspaper started in 1986 and fought, among other things, for free and fair elections and the return of democracy it was stated by the then PNC government that the Stabroek News supported the opposition and was against the government.

Free and independent newspapers must learn to live with this perennial criticism. If they are doing their job they will inevitably from time to time criticise various policies and actions of the government. The worse the quality of government the more frequent will be their critiques and these critiques will inevitably sometimes be similar to those put forward by the political opposition.

It is, however, a massive leap from this to the statement that a newspaper is politically aligned with the political opposition. That is entirely untrue in our case. We are not aligned to any political party and call the shots as we see them based on our understanding of the situation.

On the question of media ethics, this newspaper has from the outset sought to operate in a professional manner and to seek all relevant sides of a particular issue being reported on. As stated previously, this is sometimes not possible where government employees or other persons are unwilling to offer their views on particular issues.
Comment is free, facts are sacred. News items should be reported as fairly and objectively as possible, free from any editorial bias.

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Freddy Fooled

Ok! Of all the more than a dozen pranks we heard today, a call from a close friend that Freddy Kissoon was shot takes the cake for an all fools prank.

Dozens of educated Guyanese are calling each other to verify the good/bad news.

Freddy if you are safe and sound, please send us a mail.

April 1, Politicians day

Not much can be said about April 1 in Guyana, but we here at Guyana360 would like to humbly proposed that April 1 be set aside to reflect on Politicians in Guyana.

Some might say, this is a foolish idea, but we never expected a lesser comment. After all its April 1 and who forgets the fools in their lives on that day. Why should Guyana forget those who brought us thus far?

Breaking news on all fools day

Unconfirmed reports indicate that an early morning fire at Land of Canaan claimed the life of three persons: Basmat Arjune, 63; Melvina Singh, 7; and Shamar John McPherson, 5. Another person was injured and is now a patient at the Georgetown Public Hospital

Government convulsions continue

The AFC and the GAP-ROAR Parliamentary parties on Thursday, March 27, 2008 took a decision to refrain from participating in the debate on a Motion brought by the Government ostensibly to endorse and give life to the Stakeholders Engagement which ensued over a period of several days at the Office of The President.

We note that since January 26 to today’s date there has been no significant development leading to the capturing and dismantling of the criminal gang or gangs that have been responsible for the Agricola, Lusignan, and Bartica massacres, and for the murders of journalist Ronald Waddell and Minister Satyadeo Sawh. Despite the calm that we enjoy today we, like every other Guyanese believe that this is the calm before the storm and therefore no effort should be spared to address the security and governance concerns which are afflicting the stability and viability of the state. The spawning of gangs that lay siege to towns and communities must be seen as posing a threat to both national security and the political order. The solution therefore has to be multifaceted if it is to be successful.

In was against this backdrop that we approached the Stakeholders’ meetings which were chaired by the President. We indicated before, during, and after those meetings that the coming together of all stakeholders was a necessary first step to addressing the terror that was stalking the land and the challenges that this posed to governance. We expected therefore that the engagements would be treated seriously, comprehensively, and be conducted in an atmosphere of mutual respect and understanding of each others concerns and indeed the nation’s desires.

Many wholesome recommendations have been made by stakeholders coming from both the political and civil society components and it was our understanding, and that of most others with whom we have conferred, that the agreements reached presumably in good faith at the Office of the President were the beginning of a series of engagements which would lead to the substantial reform. In fact, even the Office of the President hailed the outcome as being historic and awesome which would pave the way for a new dispensation in Guyana.

When therefore we were given copies of the Motion submitted by the Prime Minister and asked to submit amendments we did so with the belief that such a historic outcome should be given expression in a Motion that truly reflected not only what was agreed initially, but also what hopes and expectations we all had for the way forward. More importantly, such a Motion should be reinforced by Resolutions which would crystallize our united condemnation of crime; recognize our individual and collective responsibilities towards establishing a united, peaceful and prosperous state in which all citizens feel duly represented in the decision making process; and give birth to the era of cooperation and inclusively that has eluded and had been denied us for the past decades.

The Prime Minister’s Motion had two accompanying resolve clauses which with all due respect to him, fell far below the minimum expectations of the stakeholders. These were:

  1. That the National Assembly takes note of those engagements and accepts the output as reflecting consensus on the agreed upon actions; and
  2. That the national Assembly in accepting that the national consensus was arrived at during those meetings with the President and the Stakeholders undertakes to provide its fullest support and to assign its highest priority in implementing commitments that called for action by Parliamentary bodies.

Our suggested amendments to the Motion were therefore few, but nonetheless consistent with the spirit of the “Bourda Accord” and for the benefit of all, these included:

  1. That a reference be made to Article 13 of the Constitution which enjoins all stakeholders to work towards the establishment of an “inclusive democracy” in which every citizen will be guaranteed a say on the decision-making process;
  2. That all parliamentary parties be given equitable access to the State media being the Guyana Chronicle and NCN to present their views and opinions;
  3. That Freedom of Information legislation is supported and enacted by all; and
  4. That the National Assembly accepts that an appropriate mechanism must be found to deepen and strengthen the Stakeholders process and to pursue all the recommendations made including the need for a holistic approach to crime solving by addressing the root causes of criminal and political violence, and other governance issues.

Bearing in mind we had the previous day assigned Opposition’s business calling for an investigation into GPL, the establishment of a Law Reform Commission, and the limiting of the ability of the Government to grant debt right-offs, were unceremoniously and selfishly dispatched by the Government, we all believed that the Government would at least appreciate the sensitivity of the moment and the political expediency of maintaining an atmosphere of compromise and cooperation in a parliamentary democracy such as ours by agreeing to all or some of our suggested amendments.

It goes without saying that the unanimous support of all the parliamentary parties was required for a Motion such as this and to that extent therefore the views of the parties must be included as long as the spirit and intent of the Stakeholders Engagement was not violated. Unfortunately, the Government had a different opinion and gave the parties a fait accompli as if to say it is our way and no other way.

We cannot accept this; and therefore had to demonstrate our displeasure and disgust.

In those unhelpful and uncompromising circumstances the AFC and GAP-ROAR did not see the need for any further participation in last Thursday’s Parliamentary session in view of the stubborn and unreasonable stance of the PPP/C Government in not supporting the amendments to the Prime Minister’s Motion on the Stakeholders’ Agreement tabled by GAP/ROAR Member, Everall Franklin.

Mr. Franklin’s amendments are wholly in keeping with the letter, spirit and intendment of the entire Stakeholders’ Agreement which was recently signed onto at the Office of the President.

Our parties stand firmly to that Agreement and expect implementation of the specific terms and all consequential matters as early as possible, and remains ready and willing to proceed on the bases of sincerity, trust, and respect.

By not supporting these amendments which sought to strengthen the Stakeholders’ Agreement, the government is showing a naked contempt for the parliamentary process and the stakeholders. By doing so they displayed a continuing attitude and approach of not giving any quarter to the Opposition’s proposals in and out of the National Assembly. This was flagrantly demonstrated on Wednesday, March 26th, 2008 when it refused to show any semblance of compromise towards the Motions presented by the Opposition on the GPL, the Law Reform Commission and the capping at ten million dollars the sum the Minister of Finance can forgive an obligation owed to the State.

The AFC and GAP-ROAR felt that to have proceeded with that charade would have meant the endorsement and perpetuation of the disregard and disrespect growing against the Parliament of Guyana among our supporters; but more significantly, it would have been to denigrate the expectation reposed by the Guyanese people in the Stakeholders’ Agreement, the terms of which, if implemented will go a far way in allaying the security fears of the public.

The act of bringing the Motion into the National Assembly in the uncompromising manner, in which the PPP/C Government did, is just political grand-standing with the purpose of scoring cheap political points and fancy headlines.

Sad, but true...political solutions are lacking

Crisis of leadership in Guyana's political opposition


The Caribbean Guyana Institute for Democracy (CGID) says Guyana's opposition Leader, Robert Corbin, is "ineffective and lacks a vision for the country." A CGID statement Monday asserted that "The political opposition in Guyana appears to be unaware that the political opposition of a country constitutes part of the democratic process and governance framework, and must therefore, in addition to robust representation of its constituency, offer alternative plans and policies for the governance of the country."


The Institute said that Mr. Corbin and the rest of the political opposition have abdicated their constitutional responsibility and have become ineffective." The CGID statement quoted its President, Rickford Burke as saying that PNCR and opposition Leader Robert Corbin appears to be equally bankrupt on policy ideas and the acute need for political reform."



Burke further noted that "We all criticize the PPP government for its ineptitude but the truth is that Corbin and the rest of the opposition are in lockstep with this paralysis of incompetence that permeates Guyana's governance and political culture. This will only change if we all speak out," Burke maintained.


"Recently the Guyana Human Rights Association (GHRA) was moved to call on Corbin to "Up the ante against the government." They did so because he lacks the alacrity to engage the government. This appears to validate the view that he is politically compromised. We have lost confidence in him and so has a majority of his constituents. He is uninspiring and, perhaps, ought to step aside," Burke lamented.


"When the human rights association has to call on the opposition to basically do its job, there is a crisis of leadership in the opposition," he added. The CGID statement followed a press conference last Wednesday in New York where Burke declared that Guyana has no political opposition. I am terribly disappointed in Mr. Corbin's lack of leadership and resolve to confront the government through parliamentary and extra-parliamentary measures, to hold the government to account, so as to ensure good governance and that the rule of law is respected.


He said Mr. Corbin appears to be nonplussed, like a deaf man amidst a sonic boom, as the state collapses; unmoved by events and circumstances. Every week several citizens are being murdered and the Police conducts no investigations, yet these issues do not come up in Parliament.


Burke contended that the Chief Magistrate has been removed from office for no legitimate reason, the government commits crimes against humanity; including torture and extra-judicial killing, people are executed by death squads with alarming frequency, there is massive corruption in government, including law enforcement and the judiciary, and the country is overrun by drug-lords, with full complicity of the government. Amidst this crisis of governance, Mr. Corbin's response is just "talk" at a press conference.


Burke observed that Mr. Corbin is due in New York this weekend for a number of events and to address the Guyanese community. "It is all well and good for him to come to New York to raise funds but it is up to us to determine if we will continue to give our resources blindly to a leader who has done nothing for us. My advice to my countrymen and women is to gently urge the opposition leader to ride gracefully into the sunset and allow capable leadership to emerge. This would be best for his party and the country."


Attached CGID Photo (L-R): CGID Vice President Edward Meertins George, CGID President, Rickford Burke, former political prisoner, Mark Benschop, CGID Executive, Max Hinds, at a CGID press conference in New York last Wednesday.

Flowing dictatorship = No consultation, plenty confusion...

Kingston hotel development

Pipes not being laid correctly engineer says

SN, April 1, 2008

The pipe-laying in Kingston, in preparation for a US$52 million hotel investment, is not being

done to engineering specifications and poses a potential danger to the integrity of Battery Road and the pipeline itself, one prominent engineer has said.

A long pipe is being buried beneath the length of Battery Road, Kingston to channel sewage into the seabed.

This pipeline has been diverted to make way for a hotel and casino, which is supposed to carry the Marriott brand. The project is being developed by Pakistani Michael Ahmad and Italian Natale Barranco under the registered company Adam Development and Urbahn Associates (ADUA) with offices in Manhattan, New York.

The engineer, who asked not to be named, told this newspaper that the way the pipe was being buried was not according to laid-down engineering specifications. He said that this could cause the road to sink under heavy traffic after the works are completed.


He also expressed concerns about the possibility of the pipe rupturing and spilling noxious sewage in proximity to not one, but two multi-layered hotels and a number of office buildings.

“When you’re laying pipes, pipe beddings are needed,” the concerned engineer said, pointing out that the pipes were in danger of getting elliptical in shape when the weight from passing road traffic bore down on them.
According to the engineer, ADUA should have been aware of the specifications and its failure to follow them could lead to serious collapse of the road to be eventually constructed. Scepticism has been sounded about ADUA’s experience with the work it is executing.

Melville Sankies, another engineer, agreed that there was the possibility that the pipes could rupture under heavy vehicular traffic. However, he said he would have to see all the plans to give a fuller assessment of the situation.

Sankies also raised concerns about the company working in the area without first notifying residents in the neighbourhood, himself being one of them. He said the company undertaking the works did not put up sufficient signs informing the public of the project and detailing who the contractors were.

This newspaper yesterday placed a call to the office of Ahmad but was told that he wasn’t in office at the time.

Calls were also placed to the Guyana Water Incor-porated (GWI), which has overall responsibility for the sewerage system. CEO Karran Singh was not available and GWI’s public relations unit said the utility has chosen not to comment on any complaints made about the hotel development.

GWI advised that this newspaper speak to Head of the Privatisation Unit Winston Brassington, whose agency was involved in the arrangements.

However, when reached Brassington said he would not comment on the issue and then berated Stabroek News for its reporting on the hotel development, contending that the newspaper was not supportive of such investment projects.

The US$700,000 contract to divert the pipe had initially been awarded to Courtney Benn Contracting Services Limited, but was subsequently withdrawn and given to ADUA.

President Bharrat Jagdeo had said that the financiers of the project wanted their own people, who were supposed to be building the hotel, to work on the diversion of the sewage line.

The construction of the ten-storey hotel is expected to commence by the middle of this year and should be completed in 2010.

Set a thief to catch a thief

Two months on, no success for Joint Special Operations Group
allegations of drug use plaguing unit


On January 31 last, the Joint Services announced that a combat size (30-35) ‘Joint Special Operations Group (JSOG)’ was put into operation to sanitise what they called the target area (Buxton). This group has been assembled specifically to hunt down gunmen and eliminate the current threat they pose.

But almost two months into their operations there is little to show for their efforts.
So far the unit has not effected a single significant arrest despite Chief of Staff of the Guyana Defence Force (GDF), Commodore Gary Best, announcing that the special team is effectively resourced (armed).

The unit was launched in the wake of the January 26 Lusignan slaying of 11 persons, including five children.

So far only one person has been charged with that massacre which preceded another brutal attack that saw the killing of 12 persons, including three policemen, at Bartica on February 17.

The special unit comprises ranks from both the Guyana Defence Force and the police and is based at the old Target Special Squad compound at Rabbit Walk Eve Leary. According to a source close to the unit, the Joint Special Operations Group is intelligence led, meaning that the members would only respond in the wake of verified intelligence. “They have to wait on instructions before they can move and time is the essence for operations of this nature,” the source said.

This newspaper also understands that the unit only goes out at night and apart from the arrests of a few drug addicts, nothing significant has occurred to justify its existence.

There are rumours that with so little to do, some members of the unit are using their time to perform taxi duties.

According to the source, recently, security at the base has been compromised with a number of women frequenting the Rabbit Walk compound.

It was reported that a female Assistant Commissioner of Police who occupies a flat next to the base had cause to chase a number of these women who had converged on the base to meet with male ranks. “All of this could distract the ranks from their objective and cause them to lose focus. How can this total slackness be allowed to continue?” the source opined.

One member of the unit, who for obvious reasons did not wish to be named, said that when the unit was first established, they were promised several vehicles to assist with efficient movement of the ranks. However, despite the crashing of one of the two vehicles that were initially assigned to the unit, the assets available to the unit remain limited.

The unit has been plagued by allegations of drug use with one rank actually being caught smoking marijuana.

This newspaper understands that four other members of the unit were tested positive for drug use and have been replaced. The Joint Special Operations Group was established in the midst of ‘Operation Restore Order’ because of the obvious breakdown in order in certain areas, according to Commodore Best.

President Bharrat Jagdeo has mandated the unit to use all means necessary to hunt down wanted man Rondell Rawlins and his gang. The Guyanese leader had stated that the Joint Services will spare no effort to bring an end to the gang and its murderous activities. Rawlins is currently listed as Guyana’s most wanted man for allegedly committing several murders, and police have issued a $50M reward for his capture.

Rawlins resurfaced some months ago after his pregnant girlfriend, 19-year-old Tenisha Morgan, vanished mysteriously on January 18, allegedly after traveling from Buxton to Georgetown to have her baby. She has not been seen since.

Despite the $50M reward being offered, from all appearances there has been no positive response from the public.

Under the Citizens’ Security Programme, which is to come on stream soon, there is provision for a special unit to deal with violent criminal activity.

However, given the current state of affairs of the Joint Special Operations Group, the administration of the security forces will have a lot to do to ensure the effectiveness of such a unit.

Two sides of Cricket

Shoaib given five-year suspension

Fast bowler Shoaib Akhtar has been banned for five years by the Pakistan Cricket Board following a disciplinary hearing in Rawalpindi.

The 32-year-old, who was on a two-year probation for attacking team-mate Mohammad Asif with a bat, was charged with publicly criticising the PCB.

"We felt his presence damaged Pakistan cricket's image," the PCB said.

The ban covers international matches and domestic games in Pakistan but not the Twenty20 Indian Premier League.

Shoaib has been plagued by injury and controversy since he began his international career in November 1997.

Guyana360: So in Pakistan a world fast bowler can be suspended for actions that literally hurt the team, but in the West Indies players continue to show scant regard for authority.

Last year while there were wide spread speculation that the team was out partying in the wee hours of the morning prior to their World Cup encounter against Sri Lanka at the Providence Stadium, no member from the WICB uttered a single word chiding the team or at least calling for an investigation.

Now today we have senior regional batsman and former West Indies captain, Shivnarine Chanderpaul (see post below) leaving the Guyana team stranded during a regional match. Did we mention he left without telling anyone? Not only did he leave the game, but he fled to T&T undetected. In fact the coaches wanted to file a missing persons report.

This is a classic example of indiscipline, and this time the culprit must face the consequences.

Cricket lewdness

Confusion abounds after Chanderpaul jets off without notice

April 1, 2008

GEORGETOWN, Guyana, CMC – Shivnarine Chanderpaul’s unexplained absence on the second day of Guyana’s final round Carib Beer Series match against Windward Islands on Sunday, created quite a fuss.
Unbeaten on 78 overnight after Guyana had reached 312 for three on Saturday, the left-handed Chanderpaul was a no-show and match officials said no explanation had been offered for the player’s absence.

It was later revealed that Chanderpaul had left Guyana to attend the West Indies Players Association awards function in Trinidad. He returned home yesterday.
Neither Guyana manager Carl Moore nor coach Albert Smith could offer an explanation for Chanderpaul’s absence, a situation that left Windwards manager Lockhart Sebastien upset.

“This is not a curry goat match … this is a first-class encounter and things like this are allowed to happen and we wonder why West Indies cricket is in the state that it is in,” Sebastien said.

“Chanderpaul told Devon (Smith) yesterday (Saturday) that he was here just to take a knock but we assumed he was joking. If he knew he had to leave then he should not have played and given one of the other youngsters a chance.”
Coach Smith said he had not been aware that Chanderpaul had planned to ‘give up’ his wicket, adding that Chanderpaul had been a part of the selection of the final XI.
“He is our most dependable batsman and has done so much for West Indies cricket as a top-class batsman, but if he knew he was just using this game for some practice and would then leave the guys he should have at least informed me as the coach and maybe allowed one of the youngsters to play,” the long serving official said.

When the Windwards started their reply after lunch on Sunday, they refused to allow the Guyanese a substitute fielder.

A senior Guyana Cricket Board official said the Board would investigate why match officials were not informed about Chanderpaul’s absence by Guyana team officials.