Monday, October 27, 2008

Sharma takes Ramsaroop apart

Following is a response from Balkaran Sharma who waded into this piece by Peter Ramsaroop

Your acid writing directing at the Government and the President is a reflection of grudge and ignorance. So steeped are they that they blind your vision to the fact that it is President Jagdeo who through ingenuity pulled Guyana out of economic rot and brought hope and light to the people. Unless you can differentiate the tree from wood you will continue to share your state of consciousness. This state of consciousness is the substance you used to build you world of reality or perceive your truth.

You talked about, “We have a President that never managed an entity in the private sector and most ministers that are in portfolios never had any experience. You can judge which ones fit those criteria”. I am oblige to ask you, are noble state men like Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, Rajeev Gandhi, Indira Gandhi, Mandela, Fidel Castro and Clinton fill you criteria for the position they held? Since they were never involved in private sector business, according to your standard of evaluation they were misfit. To declare so is to be subjective. Regarding President Jagdeo if he is incompetent as implied in your writing then Sir S. Ramphal is a fool not to recognize that; instead he congratulated him for his recent stance against EPA. See below his message. Only a brilliant mind can recognize its kind.

Obviously you don’t have to have business experience to be a President and Ministers of a Government. And don’t ever dodge the truth that it is Business Executives that are responsible for the mess the world is faced with now. Their greed and poor management brought millions to poverty and no one can speculate where the economic debacle would end.

Theories are mere theories, that is to say, mental conception which are only representation or images of reality; they are not the reality at all. When you say something, you utter only words. Therefore it would be good to allow yourself to gather some experience and then write objectively. Subjective writing makes distasteful reading.

I think your MBA intellect is mismanaged.

Sir Shridath Ramphal sends Congratulatory Message to President Bharrat Jagdeo (For having had the courage to stand up to the EU on a matter of principle and won out in the end) Congratulations! Your wise and courageous efforts over the EPA have been vindicated. The amendment of the EPA has come out well for the Caribbean and could have been even better had the rest of CARICOM shown some mettle. History will record, and the ACP will remember, that Guyana made a brave and noble stand when the Caribbean collapsed before a European negotiating offensive.You have prevented October 15 being remembered as a ‘day of shame’ in the Region. I am glad that your media statement today serves notice of the struggles ahead; struggles in which I do not believe you will be as lonely as you have been so far.The silent majority in the Caribbean, who have been with you throughout, will become more assertive; and Europe will discover that this was not the ‘victory’ they believed it was. Well before the first ‘mandatory’ review, a new EPA will emerge in a new time. You will have helped to shape the new ‘partnership’, and the new time is surely already at hand.

4 comments:

  1. This was the Response Mr. Ramsaroop sent to Mr. Sharma:

    Dear Mr. Sharma

    Your comments are all noted and reflects your thoughtful discussion.

    I would advise you read the Auditor General Report and help me account for the billions missing or misappropriated. How do we account for only a few chosen ones getting all the contracts.? How do we account for expensive houses by Ministers and Family when they only make less than $2000 US a month.?

    I will support your reflections on past leaders like Gandhi, the BIG difference is Integrity, Accountability and Transparency that made them great leaders. We are sure lacking in that regard from our Government. Study closely the concessions given to QAI. Study why 2 Years of Drugs were bought from the NGPC when we all know no drugs have that long of a shelf life. Come with me to the Hospital and look at the inventory system, we did and could not find billions of drugs bought. The Minister said “He got a good deal” so they purchased two years of drugs”

    I agree though that corporate greed is now as big as corrupt governments around the world as we see in Guyana. I experience daily the corruption.

    I would support the President fully if he had accountability of our tax payers money. It was the ERP of the 1990s that changed the Economy from The Burnham era, but study the numbers today.

    40% GDP = Remittances
    40% Drug/Underground Money
    20% Real GDP.

    We will collapse our economy if any those numbers are affected.

    I really honestly do appreciate your comments and you taking time to discuss.

    Best Regards,

    Peter R.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why do you even answer that idiot. Good articles keep writing them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i"m sure that Sharma lives in some country where Accountability and transparency are 'institutionalised'. I wonder why he's enduring the cold when he could return with his foreign exchange and family to Rajah (Roger)and Bharrat kingdom and live!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Mr. Sharma,

    We don't necessarily say 'acid writing' in English. Educated people prefer to use the word 'acerbic'.

    I must admit that you dealt a good blow when you said "I am oblige [sic] to ask you, are noble state [sic] men like Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, Rajeev Gandhi, Indira Gandhi, Mandela, Fidel Castro and Clinton fill you [sic] criteria for the position [sic]they held? Since they were never involved in private sector business, according to your standard of evaluation they were misfit. [sic] " It was, unfortunately, the only thing that made sense in your entire argument.

    I like the way that you jumped all over Roop's opening blunder, but then you failed to make sense on any other matter.

    What was subjective about his writing? What in Roop's writing showed "a reflection of grudge and ignorance."? Why were you rambling that "Theories are mere theories"? That entire paragraph was without an iota of sense. What did Roop write that lead you to believe that his "MBA intellect is mismanaged"?

    All that crap you uttered, plus adding "that it is President Jagdeo who through ingenuity pulled Guyana out of economic rot and brought hope and light to the people" reduced your one good comment to nothingness. You negated an excellent point by smothering it in a skundle of bunt.

    Your drivel caused me to read Roop's comment again, and I realised that it was some of his better writing. Apart from his one blunder, Roop's piece was sensible and amusing at the same time. The analogy of a government to business was not entirely correct, but the points were effective.

    I’d like to congratulate Guyana 360 for having a blog good enough fort Roop to read, and I would like to urge Roop to continue writing. I want to comment more about Roop’s whole ‘Vision Guyana’ thingy, and how narcissism kills the ascendance of any viable third party, but I shall do that when the opportunity arises.

    Yours truly,

    Silver Dragon

    (P.S.....Sharma, pleeze larn sam grammah).

    ReplyDelete